Jennifer Lagner Secures Atlantic Beach Commission Seat via Coin Toss

In a rare electoral twist, Jennifer Lagner clinched victory over Lisa Herrold after a coin toss decided their tie in Florida.

A
Aapla Nagpur Desk
20 Nov 2026, 5:28 PM IST · 2 min read
Source: NDTV
Jennifer Lagner Secures Atlantic Beach Commission Seat via Coin Toss
KEY TAKEAWAYS
1

Jennifer Lagner and Lisa Herrold each received 3,162 votes in the election.

2

The tie was resolved with a coin toss, a legal method under Florida law.

3

This unusual tiebreaker follows a similar incident in Duval County in 2014.

In an unprecedented electoral event, Jennifer Lagner emerged victorious in the Atlantic Beach City Commission race after a coin toss determined the outcome. The election, held on November 3, resulted in both Lagner and her opponent, Lisa Herrold, receiving an identical number of votes—3,162 each. This rare situation led election officials to resort to a coin toss at the Duval County Supervisor of Elections office in Jacksonville on November 13.

The coin toss was conducted under specific rules that allowed for a best-of-three format. Herrold called heads for the first toss, but the coin landed on tails, granting Lagner the initial win. Lagner then called heads for the second toss, which also resulted in a win for her. With two wins secured, there was no need for a third toss, and Lagner was declared the winner in a matter of approximately 20 seconds.

Prior to the coin toss, there was a possibility that an overseas ballot could have influenced the outcome. However, when officials opened the ballot received on November 12, they found it was left blank for the Atlantic Beach Commission race, confirming the tie remained unbroken and necessitating the coin toss.

Lagner expressed her thoughts on the unusual resolution, stating, "This shows how great and free our country is." Herrold, the losing candidate, reflected on their shared community ties, remarking on the significance of the event. The legal framework in Florida permits such a method of resolving electoral ties, making this coin toss a valid and recognized approach.

Interestingly, this is not the first instance of an unconventional tiebreaker in Duval County. In 2014, a tied race for the Neptune Beach City Council was resolved by drawing numbered ping-pong balls, showcasing the county's history of unique electoral resolutions. As the community reflects on this unusual election outcome, it raises questions about the implications of such methods in future elections.

💬What did you think of this story?What did you think?

Read Next

Jennifer Lagner Wins Election by Coin Toss