Supreme Court Reinstates Nagpur Teacher with Full Back Wages
The Supreme Court has overturned a previous ruling, reinstating teacher Kiran Bhujade with full back wages after a biased inquiry was identified.
The Supreme Court found significant bias in the disciplinary inquiry against Kiran Bhujade.
The court emphasized that actual prejudice does not need to be proven for bias to be established.
Bhujade's reinstatement includes continuity of service and consideration for placement in another school.
In a significant ruling on November 17, 2026, the Supreme Court of India reinstated Kiran Bhujade, a teacher from Nagpur, with full back wages and continuity of service. This decision came after the court determined that the disciplinary process against her was compromised due to familial ties among key participants in the inquiry. The court's ruling reversed the Bombay High Court's earlier judgment from April 29, 2025, and reinstated the School Tribunal's order from March 21, 2024, which had favored Bhujade's reinstatement.
Kiran Bhujade began her career as an assistant teacher in 2009 but faced exclusion from salary grants by the school management. Following her complaints, a committee found her unjustly omitted from the grant-in-aid salary lists. However, the management subsequently initiated disciplinary proceedings against her, alleging misconduct, which led to her termination on February 24, 2022. Bhujade contested both the charges and the fairness of the inquiry process.
The Supreme Court's investigation revealed that the inquiry's convenor, Prakash Masurkar, was related to the complainant, Rajesh Masurkar, who also served as a key witness and prosecutor. The court noted that Rajesh's dual role created a conflict of interest, as he was the sole witness for a significant number of charges against Bhujade. The justices highlighted that having close relatives involved in both prosecution and adjudication deprived Bhujade of a fair hearing.
The court rejected arguments from the institution that kinship alone was not sufficient to demonstrate bias without specific evidence of prejudice. It clarified that the mere potential for bias, as perceived by a reasonable observer, was adequate to question the integrity of the inquiry process. The justices also pointed out that procedural adherence could not rectify inherent biases within the decision-making framework.
In addition to restoring Bhujade's position, the court instructed the Education Officer to explore the possibility of placing her in another school that qualifies for 100% grant-in-aid, emphasizing that this was a consideration rather than a mandate. This ruling not only reinstates Bhujade but also sets a precedent regarding the importance of impartiality in disciplinary proceedings within educational institutions.




