Homebuyer Secures Rs 1.26 Crore Refund from Builder
A Nagpur-based homebuyer wins a significant refund after the national consumer commission rules against a developer for failing to deliver a flat.
The national consumer commission orders a refund of Rs 1.26 crore to a Nagpur homebuyer.
The developer failed to deliver the flat within the promised timeframe, leading to the ruling.
The commission also mandated a 9% annual interest on the refunded amount.
In a landmark decision, the national consumer commission has mandated a Nagpur real estate developer to refund over Rs 1.26 crore to a homebuyer, Pratap Premchand Agarwal, due to the developer's failure to deliver a flat within the agreed timeline. The commission's ruling, issued on November 18, 2026, also includes a directive for the developer to pay 9% annual interest on the refundable amount from the date of payment until it is fully realized.
The case dates back to November 21, 2011, when Agarwal booked a flat in the Wisteria Tower of the Enrico Heights project, paying an initial amount of Rs 11 lakh. Following this, an allotment confirmation was executed in September 2012 for a flat priced at Rs 1,70,74,500. The developer received substantial payments, totaling Rs 60,00,350, and an agreement for construction was signed in April 2013. However, despite these payments, the project remained incomplete, and the flat was not delivered in a habitable condition.
Agarwal's complaint highlighted that although possession was offered on July 18, 2019, the flat was found to be unfit for occupation during an inspection in August 2019. He raised concerns regarding the flat's area and promised amenities, ultimately seeking a refund of Rs 1,82,55,626 along with compensation calculated at 24% annual interest. The developer contested these allegations, claiming Agarwal had defaulted on his housing loan, which led to recovery actions by Canara Bank.
The commission, led by Justice Sudip Ahluwalia and Dr. Sadhna Shanker, noted that the construction agreement stipulated completion within 30 months, by October 12, 2015. The developer's claims of a grace period were deemed insufficient, as possession was only offered four years later. The commission found no valid Completion or Occupation Certificates were presented, and the developer's payment to Canara Bank for the housing loan could not be deducted from the refund amount owed to Agarwal.
In its final order, the commission directed Universal Drinks Pvt Ltd to refund Rs 1,26,44,365.97, which includes direct payments made by Agarwal and those made through EMIs to Canara Bank. The developer must comply within eight weeks, or the refundable amount will accrue interest at 12% annually during any period of default. This ruling underscores the consumer rights upheld by the commission in real estate transactions.




