Punjab HC Questions Centre's Denial of Mann's France Visit
The Punjab and Haryana High Court challenges the Centre's refusal of political clearance for CM Bhagwant Mann's trip to France for a trade fair.
The High Court criticized the Centre for not providing clear reasons for denying clearance.
CM Bhagwant Mann's visit to France aims to promote trade and engage with international buyers.
The court emphasized that political clearance should not hinge on the CM's functional role.
In a significant ruling, the Punjab and Haryana High Court has raised concerns over the Centre's refusal to grant political clearance for Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann's visit to France. The court's detailed order was released on Saturday, following its decision to allow Mann to attend the SIAL Paris 2026, a prominent food and beverage innovation trade fair, scheduled from October 17 to 21.
The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) had previously denied Mann's request, citing a vague 'political angle' without elaborating on its implications. The court pointed out that the MEA failed to clarify what this political angle entailed, questioning the rationale behind the denial. Justice Tribhuvan Dahiya, presiding over the case, rejected the Centre's argument that Mann lacked a functional role during the visit, asserting that the Chief Minister would indeed lead the delegation.
The High Court's ruling came after the Punjab government filed a petition challenging the MEA's decision. The court noted that the absence of a formal invitation from the French government, cited by the Centre, was unfounded. A letter from SIAL to the French Embassy explicitly welcomed Mann's participation, indicating the potential for establishing professional connections and negotiating contracts.
The implications of this ruling extend beyond Mann's individual trip. The court's decision underscores the importance of transparency and accountability in government actions, particularly regarding international relations. The Punjab government argued that the refusal was arbitrary and communicated too late, jeopardizing the planned visit and its objectives, which included fostering direct engagement with international buyers and promoting investment opportunities in the food sector.
Looking ahead, the Punjab government is expected to proceed with the planned visit, aiming to enhance trade relations and showcase local products at the SIAL exhibition. The court's ruling may also prompt a review of the MEA's protocols regarding political clearances for future delegations, emphasizing the need for clarity and justification in such decisions.
