INDIA Bloc Challenges ECI's Unanimity Claims in Supreme Court

Opposition leaders seek clarity on Election Commission's decisions and processes related to Special Intensive Revision.

A
Aapla Nagpur Desk
16 Nov 2026, 6:33 PM IST · 3 min read
Source: Livelaw
INDIA Bloc Challenges ECI's Unanimity Claims in Supreme Court
KEY TAKEAWAYS
1

INDIA Bloc files 48 queries regarding ECI's counter-affidavit on SIR.

2

Questions raised about the approval process and objections from Election Commissioners.

3

Supreme Court to review the petition challenging the ECI's decision-making.

In a significant legal move, leaders from the INDIA Bloc, including Rahul Gandhi, have submitted an application to the Supreme Court, posing 48 queries aimed at scrutinizing the Election Commission of India's (ECI) counter-affidavit. This counter-affidavit, filed on October 26, asserts that all decisions regarding the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) were made unanimously by the Commission. The opposition leaders are questioning the validity of this claim, citing a lack of supporting documentation such as dates and file numbers.

The application highlights concerns over the ECI's assertion of unanimous decision-making, particularly regarding the approval of a counter-affidavit submitted by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu. The petitioners are demanding clarity on whether the affidavit received approval through meetings, file circulation, or electronic communication. They are also seeking detailed records that would confirm how each of the three Election Commissioners endorsed the affidavit, along with the specific dates of these approvals.

In addition to querying the approval process, the petitioners are requesting information on any objections or reservations recorded by the Election Commissioners concerning decisions related to the SIR. They have asked for the number of instances between February 19, 2025, and October 26, 2026, when any Commissioner documented dissent regarding these decisions. This inquiry aims to ascertain whether the decisions were genuinely made unanimously or by majority.

The implications of these queries extend beyond mere procedural transparency. The opposition leaders are also challenging the ECI's claims regarding specific SIR orders issued on June 24, October 27, 2025, and May 14, 2026, which the ECI stated were based on unanimous decisions. The petitioners are demanding file numbers and the methods by which these decisions were reached, including whether they were made during meetings or through electronic means. Furthermore, they are questioning discrepancies between the ECI's affidavit and a prior order from its First Appellate Authority, which suggested that no decision had been made to initiate a nationwide SIR in 2025.

The ongoing legal battle is set against the backdrop of broader concerns regarding the ECI's operational integrity during the SIR process. The Supreme Court has already issued a notice regarding the petition filed by the INDIA Bloc, which seeks to unveil the internal decision-making processes of the ECI. The outcome of this case could have significant ramifications for the electoral landscape in India, particularly concerning the transparency and accountability of the Election Commission.

As the case progresses, the Supreme Court's examination of the ECI's practices will be closely watched, with potential implications for future electoral processes and governance in India. The next hearing dates and further developments in this case will be crucial in determining the ECI's operational legitimacy and the opposition's claims of procedural irregularities.

💬What did you think of this story?What did you think?

Read Next