Government Seeks Supreme Court Review of Yes Bank Bond Ruling
The Union government has filed a petition for a review of the Supreme Court's recent judgment regarding Yes Bank's AT-1 bonds.
The Supreme Court's October 15 ruling overturned a write-off of Rs 8,415 crore for Yes Bank's AT-1 bonds.
The review petition was filed on November 17, 2023, and is currently pending.
Both the Reserve Bank of India and Yes Bank have also sought reviews of the judgment, citing potential impacts on capital ratios.
The Union government has approached the Supreme Court to request a review of its decision made on October 15, which invalidated the write-off of Rs 8,415 crore pertaining to Yes Bank's additional tier-1 (AT-1) bonds. This legal action adds complexity to the ongoing disputes surrounding the bank's reconstruction process initiated in 2020.
The petition, titled "Union of India vs Axis Trustee Services Limited," was submitted on November 17 and is currently under consideration. This move follows similar petitions from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and Yes Bank, both of which are seeking to challenge the Supreme Court's ruling.
In its October ruling, the Supreme Court dismissed appeals from Yes Bank, the RBI, and the Union government, thereby upholding a January 2023 decision from the Bombay High Court that annulled the write-off of the AT-1 bonds. The court determined that the administrator responsible for overseeing Yes Bank's reconstruction lacked the authority to write down the bonds after the final reconstruction scheme was enacted, as the provision allowing for such a write-down had been removed from the approved scheme.
The controversy centers around two issuances of AT-1 bonds totaling Rs 8,415 crore, which Yes Bank had fully written down in March 2020 due to a significant decline in its financial health. Following the Supreme Court's verdict, Axis Trustee Services, representing the bondholders, has sought the reinstatement of the written-off bonds and initiated contempt proceedings against Yes Bank and certain officials for failing to comply with the court's orders.
The RBI's review petition argues that reversing the write-down could jeopardize the integrity of AT-1 bonds as capital instruments designed to absorb losses, thus affecting the broader banking system's resolution framework. Yes Bank's request for a review is also significant, as it could impact the bank's capital position, with estimates suggesting that restoring the bonds might decrease its Common Equity Tier-1 (CET1) capital ratio by approximately 250 basis points by June 2026.




